‘I ask him to cease’: French bishop ends more than 40 years of the Traditional Latin Mass at private chapel
Following the death of a priest who had celebrated the Traditional Latin Mass at a private chapel in the Vendée since 1983, the Bishop of Luçon has ordered his successor, a priest of the Institute of the Good Shepherd, to cease celebrating Mass there
The Bishop of Luçon has ordered a priest of the Institute of the Good Shepherd (IBP) to cease celebrating the Traditional Latin Mass on a private property in the Vendée.
Bishop Renauld de Dinechin issued the instruction in a letter dated 25 October 2026 to the faithful attending the Chapel of the Holy Family at Ramberge Castle in La Gaubretière, in the Vendée. The decision concerns Father Jean Cuchet, who took over celebrations at the chapel following the death of its previous priest, Father Jehan de Durat, in December 2025.
The letter, obtained by Le Courrier de l’Ouest, makes clear that the Bishop does not intend to permit the continuation of religious services at the chapel under Father Cuchet.
“I cannot accept that this situation continues. I ask him to cease holding religious services and related activities there,” Bishop de Dinechin wrote.
The instruction also extends to activities associated with the chapel, including catechism classes for children, which have come under scrutiny from the diocese.
The dispute centres on the succession following Father de Durat’s death on 8 December 2025. The priest had celebrated the Traditional Latin Mass at Ramberge since 1983. He was also the owner of the château, on whose grounds the Chapel of the Holy Family is situated.
Abbé Jehan de Durat spent his entire priestly life in a form of canonical limbo. Refused ordination in France because he wanted to be ordained according to the 1962 rite of ordination, he was incardinated in 1982 in the Spanish Diocese of Cuenca by the conservative Bishop José Guerra Campos.
According to the Bishop’s account in the letter, Father de Durat’s initiative had neither sought nor obtained canonical recognition from the diocese. Nevertheless, the celebrations continued for more than 40 years, with the chapel becoming a regular destination for traditional Catholics from the Vendée and neighbouring areas.
The congregation reportedly numbered between 150 and 300 people each Sunday, drawing worshippers from the Choletais, the Nantes area and the Bressuirais.
Following Father de Durat’s death, Father Cuchet, a priest of the Institute of the Good Shepherd, continued the celebrations. He had initially come to Ramberge at the request of his superiors to assist Father de Durat.
However, Bishop de Dinechin maintains that the arrangement was made without his authorisation. “With the death of Father de Durat, the situation has changed,” the Bishop wrote, explaining why His Excellency would not permit the new arrangement to continue.
The Bishop added that Father Cuchet’s presence at Ramberge had arisen “without the bishop’s agreement”, before reiterating that he could not accept the continuation of religious services and associated activities.
The Bishop also rejected the possibility of granting canonical recognition to the community assembled at the chapel. “I will not grant canonical recognition to the assembly meeting in Ramberge,” His Excellency wrote.
He referred specifically to the instructions issued under Pope Francis in December 2021, following the publication of the apostolic letter Traditionis Custodes, which placed the celebration of the Traditional Latin Mass under the authority of diocesan bishops and restricted the establishment of new personal parishes.
You can bless twice as many children with a Christmas gift and the love of Jesus — thanks to a $40,000 Matching Grant.
“Pope Francis explicitly asked bishops to halt the establishment of new personal parishes. I cannot grant canonical recognition to the chapel in Ramberge,” Bishop de Dinechin stated.
The Bishop’s reference to the absence of canonical recognition is central to his decision. Although Mass had been celebrated at Ramberge since 1983, the arrangement had continued without formal recognition from the diocese.
Bishop de Dinechin has nevertheless indicated that the faithful who attended Ramberge should seek other places where the older Roman rite is celebrated in communion with the diocesan bishop and the Pope.
In his letter, he identified four alternative locations: Bellefontaine Abbey in Maine-et-Loire, near Cholet; the chapel of the religious sisters of the Victims of the Sacred Heart of Jesus in Chavagnes-en-Paillers; the chapel of the Collège de l’Espérance in Sainte-Cécile; and Notre-Dame Church in La Roche-sur-Yon.
The Bishop acknowledged that the decision would be difficult for those accustomed to attending the chapel and appealed to them to remain obedient to the Church.
“For a number of people […], this step will not be easy. I offer them my prayers. May God allow each one to find the right way to renew their bond in obedience to the Church. Obedience to the Church is fruitful. In this time of trial, I offer you my prayers,” he concluded.
The Institute of the Good Shepherd, to which Father Cuchet belongs, is a society of apostolic life established in 2006 under Pope Benedict XVI. Its priests celebrate according to the traditional Roman liturgy.
Father de Durat, who died aged 70, had served the chapel since 1983. His funeral Mass was celebrated in the parish church of La Gaubretière on 13 December 2025.
Bishop de Dinechin, who was appointed Bishop of Luçon by Pope Leo XIV in September 2025 and installed in December that year, has now made clear that the continuation of the community’s activities under Father Cuchet will not be permitted.
Bishop de Dinechin’s decision does not, however, mean that he has been opposed to the Traditional Latin Mass throughout his episcopal ministry. On 27 June 2020, while serving as Bishop of Soissons, Laon and Saint-Quentin, he ordained three seminarians of the Priestly Fraternity of St Peter (FSSP) to the priesthood at Laon Cathedral.
The decision in Luçon follows several other disputes over the celebration of the Traditional Latin Mass in French dioceses since the introduction of Traditionis Custodes in 2021. In Dijon, Archbishop Roland Minnerath ended the Priestly Fraternity of St Peter’s (FSSP) 23-year presence at the Basilica of Saint-Bernard in Fontaine-lès-Dijon.
In the Diocese of Quimper and Léon, Bishop Laurent Dognin ended the agreement with the FSSP in late 2023 and early 2024, bringing its apostolate at Saint-Mathieu in Quimper and Sainte-Sève to an end. The diocese raised concerns about the community’s autonomous functioning and its relationship with diocesan structures.
A similar reorganisation took place in the Diocese of Valence, where Bishop François Durand announced in May 2025 that responsibility for the Traditional Latin Mass would pass to diocesan clergy from September that year.
In Paris, Archbishop Michel Aupetit reduced the number of authorised locations for the Traditional Latin Mass in 2021, limiting celebrations to five churches. He also introduced requirements concerning written authorisation for celebrants, the use of readings from the official vernacular lectionary and the preference for priests willing to celebrate according to both the traditional and modern Roman rites.
